The Contraception4All homepage
Sep 2024 - Current

My Choice For All

Earning trust for a health site no one had heard of.

Website: contraception4all.info

HealthcareTrust & CredibilityInclusive DesignResearch-BasedUser PrivacyWeb Design
Team
Design Lead (me)
Researcher
Junior Designer
Impact
Presented @ AMIA Annual Symposium 2025

Overview

My Choice For All is a government-funded project that helps transgender people find the contraceptive methods that fit their individual needs. I’m the design lead on a 3-person design team, and we built the website from scratch.

The problem

People didn’t trust our site.

It came up in our first interviews, while we were talking about color palettes. The clinic and medical students had reviewed every page, and people knew who we were, but they still felt unsure about us. So what about people who’ve never heard of us?

  • Old website: start page

    Old website: start page

  • Old website: method history questions

    Old website: method history questions

  • Old website: recommendation table

    Old website: recommendation table

Why it matters

In healthcare, and any other high-stakes industry, building trust is so important because it’s the foundation of how users think about a product. If the trust isn’t there, no matter how great, how accurate or how decent we think we are, it means nothing to the user.

Solution Highlights

How do we earn trust when no one has heard of us?

  • Visual heuristic cues

  • Clear sources

  • If we don’t collect data, say it out loud

Research

Trust is super complex and shaped by many factors…

Psychology, human factors and many other fields have studied how a sense of trust forms. I found this taxonomy helpful for breaking down which factors go into it, so we could start from there.

Design can’t do all the work, but I can decide what to present to the user.

Diagram adapted from Karuna, P., Purohit, H., & Motti, V. (2019). UTPO: User’s Trust Profile Ontology – Modeling trust towards Online Health Information Sources. arXiv:1901.01276.
Who we should focus on: the least familiar visitor!

Visitors come from different sources, and that affects how they see us even before they start reading our content. I decided to focus on the organic search visitor. They know what they’re looking for: contraceptive methods, transgender health, recommendations, etc. But no one vouches for us.

How visitors find My Choice For All, who vouched for us, and the trust level they arrive with. Organic search: the least familiar visitor.
How they found usWho vouched for usStarting trust level
Clinician“My doctor sent me.”High
Friends“A friend told me about it.”High
Online community“Someone in a trans group I’m in shared it.”High
AI chatbot“An AI chatbot suggested it.”Medium
Organic searchNobodyLow

Design Direction

So we gotta place trust signals… but what, when, where?

These are the thoughts a visitor might have when they visit us for the first time. They may not come in exactly this order, but the questions always pop up. I made sure to place each signal at the right time and in the right place.

Moment 01

The first few seconds
  • What is this site?
  • Am I in the right place?
  • Is it for someone like me?
[1] Visual heuristic cues

Transgender flag colors, plus a clear hero image that says who we serve up front.

[2] Who’s behind us, right in the hero

I put who’s behind us in the hero section too, and made sure everything fits in the first screen (100vh), so nothing gets cut off on any device.

Moment 02

While reading
  • Who made this?
  • Where is the info from?
[1] A real About Us page

There wasn’t an About Us page before. Now we have one, and it’s a well-curated page with our team, our story and our values!

[2] Clear sources

All our content links to third-party, authoritative sources! I also made sure we don’t use an academic citation format, since it might scare the general public away.

Moment 03

Before taking action
  • Is my privacy safe?
  • Is it risky?
  • What do I do next?
  • Who can I ask?
[1] If we don’t collect data, say it out loud

Personal health info can be sensitive. We’d already decided not to collect it, so the user should know that too.

[2] Explain our recommendations

Every suggestion comes with “Why we suggested this”, so users can see our reasoning and decide for themselves.

[3] Be honest about our limits

A consistent disclaimer, plus “Bring this to your provider”. Being upfront about what we can’t do shows we’re confident in what we can.

[4] Give a point of contact

So users always know where to reach us, and that there are real people behind this site.

Key Decision

We had to communicate who we’re for, effectively. Visuals can do that job perfectly, but a site that’s loudly queer isn’t always safe. We don’t want to out anyone accidentally.

What we tested: Hero image

Rainbow reads fast, but it risks rainbow capitalism.

We showed three image directions in the interviews. The rainbow flags told people who we’re for in a second, but some participants felt they leaned into rainbow capitalism (and were too loud).

Three hero image options, A to C, shown in the interviews

What we tested: Color palette

Queer people are very aware of queer flag colors.

Opinions on colors varied, but most participants spotted the queer flag colors right away. A subtle hint of them is still great for recognition.

Six color palette options, A to F, shown in the interviews

Result

Real positive feedback from participants

  • “I would recommend this to my friend!”
  • “Oh, this is helpful!”
  • “I like how I can find info easily.”
Conference and papers

Co-author — Poster presentation at AMIA Annual Symposium 2025

Learning

Being a design lead and working with medical professionals

The hardest part was not the design. Internally, the cross-team goals were sometimes misaligned. Acting as the bridge that translates clinical needs into technical constraints was my biggest takeaway. I learned to use rapid prototypes to streamline communication and reduce misalignment between iterations.